Kept kicking the ball away and when we actually had a straightforward kick to draw level at 37-37 we went for the corner. Summed up our brainless play all evening. I’m really annoyed about how we played. Yet again we’ve faltered in a big match
Gavin Hegarty
Anyone else think henshaw was a huge weak link? He didn’t bring anything to the party.
Head to simani is a straight red
Yellow at the try line should be a penalty try
But we shouldn’t have been in that position.
Horrific first half that we shouldn’t have been that bad in.
Andrew Tynan
The ref giving a saints player a yellow card at the end but yet no penalty try? What?
Kevin Kelehan
Kicking the ball at Saints back 3 was never going to be a winner, Leinster were lucky to be in the game right to the end, tactically the approach did not play to Leinster’s strengths. Credit Saints they nailed 90% of their chances
Colette Caddle
They were the better side and deserved the win.
Christy O’Connor
Nienaber has to go for me, I’ve never liked his tactics and I was never hopeful we would win with his style. Yes we played better the last few weeks but against very poor opposition
Daniel James
I think we should’ve played at least the bones of this team against scarlets last week as I worry that the international are sometime undercooked. Also i think we need to win an URC before the champions cup and we have been focusing to much on getting that 5th star rather then winning our league then going for the star. The intensity from Northampton was incredible all game I expected them to get tired towards the end but they have it there all where as I thought we got tired at times and their scores seemed a bit easy.
Cuan Mulligan
Saints deserved the win. However some very dubious ref calls. The possible try at the end should not have been disallowed for the reason the ref gave, the corner flag is not in touch.. however Byrne was on the floor and it’s questionable if he is allowed to touch it down. About 2 or 3 plays before it, near their try line, I think Pollock goes off his feet crawling on his knees over our players and a second player in goes into take the ball… not sharing this to gripe.. if you leave your win down to ref calls you don’t deserve it.. but the reffing was poor
Jackie McEachern
Saints were very good (and it pains me to say that). But I don’t understand not starting Barrett.
And I’m not sure resting the starters leading up to these big games is a good strategy. I know it’s a physical game but we’ve seen time and time again where they come into the big matches rested but not cohesive.
Richard Collumb
Useless today & Tactics were terrible. That’s down to the coaches. Given team & budget the players & management get judged on performances in May & they aren’t good enough.
Get in the conversation yourself by leaving
your own thoughts each week after the full time whistle
We’re very much creatures of habit here at Harpin Manor but the past week has been crazy. Normally we have fixed content production for particular days of the week yet life has a canny knack of getting in the way eh?
So first of all the wrap pod was just myself and Conor Cronin – I reckon we did an ok job of summarizing the match all things considered, had a bit of banter online with some Scarlets fans about it. Didn’t have time to do either the “final thoughts” or the “bonus chat” videos this week unfortunately, although I am seriously thinking aboyt scaling back the weekly content anyway as my routine involves.
One thing is for sure, with two matches per week on the Lions Tour coming up, for that period alone there will need to be a massive re-think! Anyway, we’ll cross that when we get to it.
Like I mentioned earlier, I don’t have time to make the usual video and I wasn’t going to comment on my Front 5 choices either but I had to make an exception for this one.
Over the weekend there was a post on BlueSky that shed a completely new light over what should have been a story about the Women’s Six Nations clash between Scotland and Ireland.
Apparently there was to be a trophy awarded to the winner to honour the memory of Siobhán Cattigan, and this seemed to be a perfectly fitting tribute until, well, there was an intervention and her poor family were left rightly confused and heartbroken.
It has apparently since been resolved but the whole thing just served to sully further what was already a very bad show by the SRU.
Hat-tip to Ailbhe from the excellent MudderRucker podcast for helping me find the one and only article in the press about this, and indeed it was excellent gumshoe journalism by David Walsh from the Times who has followed the story since Siobhan’s tragic passing.
The article is behind a paywall and I want to respect that so I won’t go into more detail but I definitely recommend reading the full story if you can and I’m looking forward to watching the SIobhán Cattigan Trophy (or something similar, I don’t think the name has been confirmed) be awarded in the near future.
WAS FEATURE NOW BUG
Other competitions, such as cricket’s Hundred, have found a lucrative market for stakes in franchise teams free from the threat of relegation.
I think I need to write something here as well, I just discovered this article as I was putting together the column! Nice to see the Premiership have finally admitted that theirs was a failed business model after years of claiming relegation was actually the main feature.
WALL SIDELINED
The news comes a week after flanker Erin King was ruled out of the World Cup following a serious knee injury.
Major blow for Ireland as injury rules Dorothy Wall out of Women’s World Cup
Ciarán Kennedy – The42.ie
Devastating blow for Dorothy personally of course but also the full Irish squad.
SEALED WITH A KISS
They also get the reassurance of current coach Joe Schmidt continuing after the British & Irish Lions tour this winter and the Rugby Championship Tests in Spring.
“Hogg had been thriving in his new life in the south of France, operating in a surprise new position at fly-half.”
Stuart Hogg ruled out of rugby until 2026 after devastating setback
Steven S – Ruck.co.uk
While I’d never be happy about an injury to anyone, let’s just say I am a lot less gutted about this Achilles injury than I am Dorothy Wall’s. Regular Harpin readers will know the Front Five column has been following Hogg’s off-field story closely over the past while, although to read this particular story you’d think it never happened. I guess that’s their editorial choice, but I would have included a line like “Hogg, who was sentenced in January 2025 for abusing his estranged wife”, as I have here.
LEINSTER SQUAD UPDATE
Excellent news on James Ryan and Rob Russell but I very much doubt the former will be ready in time for Saturday’s semifinal so for my selection I have tried to reward those who have impressed in recent weeks for the tight decisions. Tommy O’Brien, Jack Deegan, Diarmuid Mangan and Max Deegan all fall into this category.
HARPIN’ POSSIBLE MATCHDAY 23 V NORTHAMPTON
15 H Keenan 14 T O’Brien 13 G Ringrose 12 J Barrett 11 J Lowe 10 S Prendergast 9 J Gibson-Park
1 A Porter 2 D Sheehan 3 T Furlong 4 J McCarthy 5 RG Snyman 6 J Conan 7 J vd Flier 8 C Doris (c)
16 R Kelleher 17 J Boyle 18 R Slimani 19 D Mangan 20 M Deegan 21 L McGrath 22 R Byrne 23 R Henshaw
caveat : I have no “ITK” a la Thornley
OFFICIAL UPDATE posted Monday
AVAILABLE FOR SELECTION:
RG Snyman: has returned to full training having recovered from injury.
Ryan Baird: came through the game at the weekend with no issues after his return from injury.
FURTHER ASSESSMENT REQUIRED:
Rob Russell: will look to increase his training load this week as he continues his recovery from injury and will be further assessed as the week goes on.
James Ryan: will look to increase his training load this week as he continues his recovery from injury and will be further assessed as the week goes on.
NOT AVAILABLE FOR SELECTION:
Brian Deeny: will have a procedure this week on a knee injury which will keep him out of action for the rest of the season.
Will Connors: is unavailable for selection with an arm injury and will be further assessed this week.
NO FURTHER UPDATES ON:
Jordan Larmour.
TROLL PATROL
Now it’s time for Troll Patrol where we ‘detain’ a social media commentator and charge them with gaslightery and general online mayhem.
Hat-tip to Rugby Kino for spotting this perfect follow up to last week’s Troll Patrol detainee, James has done it again as for the second week in a row, a player loaned by Leinster to Munster has ended up on the losing side, so he just reworked the same message at the same time, with a photo added for maximum effect.
I just hope the Munster fans don’t respond by finding some kind of correlation between the Leinster players’ involvement and the results…..
Qualifying finals – 1 v 6, 2 v 5, 3 v 4 with the top-ranked team hosting
Semi-Finals – three qualifying winners plus highest ranked loser: Teams re-ranked with 1 v 4 and 2 v 3
Final – top-ranked semi-final winner hosts the other semi-final winner.
RWC2027 QUALIFIERS
The RWC2027 tournament has expanded to 24 nations so with four extra spots up for grabs it makes for a fascinating qualifying process.
Rather than post the latest results and fixtures here however, I’d like to defer to the excellent work of frequent Harpin’ contributor Ciarán Duffy who has been keeping close tabs on the qualifying process over at his own site Post to Post Sport.
Follow this linkto see how the Road to Australia is progressing, Ciarán has the April update there now.
Japan League One
Major League Rugby
Harpin Prediction League
This is the 4th season of our Superbru prediction league among Harpin’ pod contributors.
Kristian is the reigning champion, but the real competition is in avoiding finishing last, which means you must wear The Jersey of Shame. I had to wear it the first year, while Keego has had the honour the past two seasons.
As you can see our resident stats expert Rugby Kino is leading the way with room to spare although Mark does seem to be gaining on him… meanwhile down at the foot of the table, a mini fightback from David sees the Jersey race up for grabs again.
We’ve also added a Cup (or Mug) competition to make things interesting, and congrats to Conor Cronin for defeating, well, me in the final last weekend. Ironically for a Leinster-based site, it was Conor’s complete lack of faith in Munster winning in Cardiff which proved the difference, that match gave him a 1.5 point swing.
26 April 2025; Will Connors of Leinster is tackled by Taine Plumtree of Scarlets during the United Rugby Championship match between Scarlets and Leinster at Parc Y Scarlets in Swansea, Wales. Photo by Chris Fairweather/Sportsfile
Really poor from almost every perspective but hopefully just a bump in the road. I know we were missing many of the first team but there were still far too many errors and poor decisions.
Christy O’Connor
Scarlets line speed was brilliant, put us under lots of pressure and caused us to make so many mistakes, granted some were unforced. Better team won
Ollie Sinnott
Ross Byrne, Frawley, the Osbornes, Tector, Baird, O Brien and Mccarthy are a couple of steps down in quality from the first 23. Only player to improve their reputation this evening was Jack Boyle and Soroka.
Bert McLoughlin
People whinging about team selection pisses me off! Apart from what’s coming next week, the team out on the field today were good enough to win the game. BUT they made way too many errors and didn’t deserve to win the game.
Congratulations to Scarlets, they played really well and deserved to win that game
Greg Kelly
Scarlets came out needing the 5 points. They were hungry and quite simply Leinster we not. Fair play to the Scarlets, they were well worth the win and showed great composure given that Leinster have a habit of clawing back games. It looked like Leinster had both eyes on Northampton and a lot of the players knew that their knockout involvement going forward was over.
Get in the conversation yourself by leaving
your own thoughts each week after the full time whistle
Considering Leinster conceded more points in the first 8 minutes v Ulster (3) than the previous 160+, there was a lot more to harp on for this week’s wrap – that said I decided to try and stick to the reduced timeframe we had used over the past two weeks and I think it worked out pretty well, with Ciarán Duffy and David Cordial providing the bulk of the wrapping between them Ciarán now sits on 199 overall contributions to Harpin’ On Rugby over the years so plans are afoot at Harpin’ Manor to properly commemorate the upcoming milestone.
A selection of eye-catching egg-chasing quotes & links from around the rugby media landscape
THINKING INSIDE THE BOX
MURPHY’S LAW
I’M STEVE
WHOLE NEW WORLD
DIVINE INTERVENTION
HARPIN ON…LEINSTER PLAYER PROFILES (PART 1)
lead-in question :
“Last week we honoured Jordie Barrett’s excellent display by looking at Leinster’s greatest imports so I suppose with the business end of the season upon us it might be a good time to turn the spotlight on the current crop of boys in blue. I have asked the panel to select a player each to harp on, starting with David who wants to feature Saturday night’s player of the match…”
LEINSTER SQUAD UPDATE
Last week when I put together my predicted Leinster 23 I failed to take two things into consideration – first, Leinster’s willingness to field much stronger URC squads even at this time of year. I wonder if Richie Murphy & co even suspected to be facing both Messrs Henshaw and Ringrose together for example. But I also forgot about the All Ireland League semifinals, which last weekend featured the names who could have played the interpro like Hugh Cooney, Charlie Tector and Cormac Foley. Since Tarf came out on top at Castle Avenue (see updates below), Tector and Foley could well be in the reckoning for Llanelli, because I have to assume there will be a lot more cotton wool used this time around.
HARPIN’ POSSIBLE MATCHDAY 23 V SCARLETS
15 H McErlean 14 J Osborne 13 L Turner 12 C Tector 11 J O’Brien 10 C Frawley 9 F Gunne
1 J Boyle 2 G McCarthy 3 T Clarkson 4 D Mangan 5 B Deeny 6 A Soroka 7 W Connors 8 M Deegan (c)
16 J McKee 17 C Healy 18 R Maguire 19 A Spicer 20 S Penny 21 C Foley 22 R Byrne 23 A Osborne
caveat : I have no “ITK” a la Thornley
OFFICIAL UPDATE posted Tuesday
AVAILABLE FOR SELECTION:
Paddy McCarthy and Will Connors: have returned to full training this week having recovered from injury.
FURTHER ASSESSMENT REQUIRED:
Ryan Baird: will be further assessed this week for a calf injury and a final decision will be made on his involvement later this week.
RG Snyman: will be further assessed this week following a dead leg against Ulster and a final decision on his involvement will be made later in the week.
NO FURTHER UPDATES ON:
Jordan Larmour, Rob Russell and James Ryan.
TROLL PATROL
Now it’s time for Troll Patrol where we ‘detain’ a social media commentator and charge them with gaslightery and general online mayhem.
Ah, James. Very bold Leinster on Munster trolling that thoroughly deserves this week’s detention. And it’s not just the comment itself, but also the timing…right after the Bulls pinched a win at Thomond Park. Naturally we here at Harpin Monor couldn’t possibly condone such online behaviour…
Qualifying finals – 1 v 6, 2 v 5, 3 v 4 with the top-ranked team hosting
Semi-Finals – three qualifying winners plus highest ranked loser: Teams re-ranked with 1 v 4 and 2 v 3
Final – top-ranked semi-final winner hosts the other semi-final winner.
RWC2027 QUALIFIERS
The RWC2027 tournament has expanded to 24 nations so with four extra spots up for grabs it makes for a fascinating qualifying process.
Rather than post the latest results and fixtures here however, I’d like to defer to the excellent work of frequent Harpin’ contributor Ciarán Duffy who has been keeping close tabs on the qualifying process over at his own site Post to Post Sport.
Follow this link to see how the Road to Australia is progressing..
Japan League One
Major League Rugby
Harpin Prediction League
This is the 4th season of our Superbru prediction league among Harpin’ pod contributors.
Kristian is the reigning champion, but the real competition is in avoiding finishing last, which means you must wear The Jersey of Shame. I had to wear it the first year, while Keego has had the honour the past two seasons.
As you can see our resident stats expert Rugby Kino is leading the way with room to spare although Mark does seem to be gaining on him… meanwhile down at the foot of the table, a mini fightback from David sees the Jersey race up for grabs again.
We’ve also added a Cup (or Mug) competition to make things interesting, with Conor pipping Tom in the second semifinal to join some guy called Jeff in the final this weekend.
19 April 2025; Tommy O’Brien of Leinster evades the tackle of on his way to scoring his side’s first try during the United Rugby Championship match between Leinster and Ulster at the Aviva Stadium in Dublin. Photo by Brendan Moran/Sportsfile
Tommy is flying, definitely in with a great shout to be playing in the cup games. Will definitely be on the irish summer tour
Greg Kelly
Tommy O’Brien looking like the real deal these days
Michael Branagan
Great result. Porter needs to be “seen to be in control”. He’s throwing penalties away, 50:50 calls, that are damaging us and his reputation. I do think it’s harsh on a number of fronts but he has to “ease back” as it were. For a little while.
William Andrew
Ulster had a lot go against them, but still hung in there.
Some unfortunate, some self inflected.
Leinster were good but you can see some players are not quite the standard of the 1st squad.
Others are pushing on. Highlights were the chip to Dan and Gunn delaying his pass to Dan.
Smart play
Warren Doyle
Right person won man of the match. Class act. Well done Tommy O’Brien.
Similar Leinster result to the previous weekend meant a similar Harpin wrap pod only this time it was Tom Coleman & Rich Mifsud providing the concise, commendable coverage on Sunday evening.
A selection of eye-catching egg-chasing quotes & links from around the rugby media landscape
BRIDGING THE GAP
PROVINCIAL TARIFF
A LOAN IT STANDS
FLAWED STRUCTURE
URC ON GEORGIA’S MIND
HARPIN ON…LEINSTER’S BEST IMPORTS
Here’s the lead-in question :
“After Jordie Barrett’s out of this world display for Leinster at the Aviva Stadium on Friday evening, I thought for this week’s bonus topic we could take a look back at some of our top imports over the years. I have asked the lads to choose two of their favourites each and I might even chip in with one of my own when they’re done. We’re going to kick things off with Rich, on whom have you chosen to harp?”
LEINSTER SQUAD UPDATE
Thought I was being super efficient having my predicted lineup done straight after the injury report came out but then the Milne/Barron news broke so I had to have another crack. Still think we’ll have a decent 23 for the visit of the Ulstermen on Saturday.
HARPIN’ POSSIBLE MATCHDAY 23 V ULSTER
15 H McErlean 14 J Osborne 13 H Cooney 12 C Tector 11 J O’Brien 10 C Frawley 9 F Gunne
1 J Boyle 2 G McCarthy 3 T Clarkson 4 D Mangan 5 B Deeny 6 A Soroka 7 W Connors 8 J Culhane
16 J McKee 17 M Milne 18 R Maguire 19 A Spicer 20 S Penny 21 C Foley 22 R Byrne 23 A Osborne
caveat : I have no “ITK” a la Thornley
OFFICIAL UPDATE posted Monday
AVAILABLE FOR SELECTION:
Rónan Kelleher: came through the game at the weekend with no issues following his return from a neck injury.
FURTHER ASSESSMENT REQUIRED:
Jack Conan: will be further assessed this week for a minor shoulder injury and a final decision will be made on his involvement later this week.
Ryan Baird: will be further assessed this week for a minor calf injury and a final decision will be made on his involvement later this week.
Paddy McCarthy, Rob Russell and Will Connors: will all step up their respective rehabilitation programmes and a final decision will be made on their involvement later this week.
NO FURTHER UPDATES ON:
Jordan Larmour and James Ryan
TROLL PATROL
Now it’s time for Troll Patrol where we ‘detain’ a social media commentator and charge them with gaslightery and general online mayhem.
This week’s Troll Patrol detainee claims to be a Leinster fan and his post touches on a topic I’m planning to cover for my Broken Play article on Substack this Saturday morning so stay tuned…
Qualifying finals – 1 v 6, 2 v 5, 3 v 4 with the top-ranked team hosting
Semi-Finals – three qualifying winners plus highest ranked loser: Teams re-ranked with 1 v 4 and 2 v 3
Final – top-ranked semi-final winner hosts the other semi-final winner.
RWC2027 QUALIFIERS
The RWC2027 tournament has expanded to 24 nations so with four extra spots up for grabs it makes for a fascinating qualifying process.
Rather than post the latest results and fixtures here however, I’d like to defer to the excellent work of frequent Harpin’ contributor Ciarán Duffy who has been keeping close tabs on the qualifying process over at his own site Post to Post Sport.
Follow this link to see how the Road to Australia is progressing..
Japan League One
Major League Rugby
Harpin Prediction League
This is the 4th season of our Superbru prediction league among Harpin’ pod contributors.
Kristian is the reigning champion, but the real competition is in avoiding finishing last, which means you must wear The Jersey of Shame. I had to wear it the first year, while Keego has had the honour the past two seasons.
As you can see our resident stats expert Rugby Kino is leading the way with room to spare but down at the foot of the table, an impressive couple of rounds has seen Keego move of the bottom for the first time in two years.
We’ve also added a Cup (or Mug) competition to make things interesting, and after this weekend we’ll know who gets to join some guy named Jeff in next week’s final, with Tom and Conor going head to head for the privilege.
11 April 2025; Dan Sheehan of Leinster scores his side’s seventh try during the Investec Champions Cup quarter-final match between Leinster and Glasgow Warriors at the Aviva Stadium in Dublin. Photo by Brendan Moran/Sportsfile
We put on a show but we learned nothing and didn’t sharpen our edges. When Byrne replaced Sam there was a noticeable drop off in incision and tempo. All in all we played an hour of solid rugby and then pulled up in the last 20 to save legs.
Chris McDonnell
Just too good. Noticeable drop off when we changed our half backs.
David Ryle
Wasn’t a scoreline we were expecting. But Glasgow were missing half of their starters.
2 weeks on the bounce teams kept scoreless.
Cuan Mulligan
Loved the term.. Leinster Double Bagel
Get in the conversation yourself by leaving
your own thoughts each week after the full time whistle
HARPIN' ON RUGBY 