549 : Sloppiness, Scrums & Success


Ireland v Fiji review, Wales v New Zealand, France v South Africa and the Nations Championship’s F10 controversy.

Seven tries, a 28-point victory and plenty of reasons to be cheerful. So why did Ireland’s 43-15 win over Fiji leave supporters feeling that something wasn’t quite right?

For Episode 549 of Harpin’ On Rugby, I’m joined by Hugo Gordon to pick through Ireland’s latest Nations Championship outing at the Aviva Stadium.

There was certainly plenty to admire. Ireland’s scrum looked increasingly assured, Ryan Baird delivered a Player of the Match performance, Andrew Porter continued his impressive return to form and Nick Timoney once again demonstrated his value to Andy Farrell’s squad.

But the evening wasn’t without its frustrations. A sloppy first half, some costly defensive lapses, problems at the breakdown and another worrying addition to the injury list all provide talking points ahead of the visit of South Africa.

Hugo also offers a slightly different perspective on the reaction to Ireland’s performance. After all, seven tries and a comfortable victory shouldn’t be dismissed too readily.

A weekend to remember

We then turn to two other major Nations Championship encounters.

Wales v New Zealand: After 73 years without a victory over the All Blacks, Wales produced a performance that will live long in the memory. We discuss the extraordinary defensive effort that helped deliver the result and what it might mean for Welsh rugby.

France v South Africa: Antoine Dupont’s unusual deployment at out-half was just one ingredient in a spectacular contest in Paris. We look at the French flair, Springbok physicality and moments of brilliance that made this one of the standout matches of the year.

Quick Tap: The Cartel Strikes Back

Finally, there’s another issue I couldn’t resist harping on.

The Nations Championship is barely underway, yet reports have emerged of concerns among established unions about the financial consequences of future relegation.

With the new F10 organisation also entering the picture, what does all this mean for emerging rugby nations hoping to earn their place at the top table?

My latest Quick Tap considers whether the competition can genuinely grow the game while protecting the interests of its established members.

Episode 549: Sloppiness, Scrums & Success

Featuring Jeff Pagano and Hugo Gordon.

Follow Harpin’ On Rugby for weekly match reviews, previews, rugby discussion and our regular Quick Tap rants.

Enjoy your rugby wherever you are!

Leave a Reply